Hodges and Tizard 1989 | Simply Psychology (31.07.2017)


Hodges and Tizard Study

Saul McLeod published 2008


Aims

  • To investigate the effect of institutional upbringing on later attachments.
  • To investigate the effects of privation on later social and emotional development.
  • To investigate if the effects of privation can be reversed.

Procedure

Jill Hodges and Barbara Tizard (1989) followed the development of 65 children who had been in residential nurseries from only a few months old.

This is known as a longitudinal study. The study was also a field experiment. The independent variable (what happened to the children at age 4) occurred naturally.

The care provided was of good quality, but carers were discouraged from forming attachments with the children (i.e. privation occurred).

By age 4, 24 children were adopted, 15 returned to their natural home (restored), and the rest stayed in institutions

They were also compared with a control group, who had spent all their lives in their own families. The control group was closely matched to the children in the experimental group. For example, in terms of sibling number, home location (London), parental occupation, position in family, age, gender etc.

The children were assessed for social and emotional competence at four, eight and sixteen years old. The assessment comprised interviewing the children and their parents and teachers and a set of questionnaires.


Findings

At four years of age none of the institutionalized children had formed attachments, but by eight years of age those who were adopted had formed good attachments. Also their social and intellectual development was better than that of children returned to their own families.

Those returned to their natural families (restored) showed more behavioral problems and the attachments were weaker. Nevertheless all those children who had spent their early years in institutions were more attention-seeking from adults and showed some difficulties in their social relationships, particularly with their peers.

Some of these children were interviewed again at 16 years of age, as were their parents and care-workers. They were compared with a new control group as the original control children no longer matched the children in the adopted and restored groups.

Hodges and Tizard found that the adopted children still had good attachments which compared favorably with the control children. Fewer restored children were reported as having good attachments but the children who had been brought up in institutional care had experienced most instability and showed some difficulties in their later attachments.


Conclusion

We can conclude from this evidence that Bowlby was correct to emphasize the importance of the early years, but the effects of delay in the formation of attachments do not necessarily persist into adulthood and lead to affectionless psychopathy, as Bowlby predicted. Indeed, loving relationships and high quality care are necessary to reverse privation effects.


Evaluation:

However, Hodges and Tizard used interviews and questionnaires, both of which can produce answers that are affected by social desirability – the wish to appear in a good light. The responses of those interviewed may have been inaccurate, and this would affect the results.

Another difficulty in this research is that six of the original 51 families of eight-year-olds refused to take part in this later research. It could be that families experiencing more difficulties were more likely to refuse, and this may also apply to the comparison group, because the families who agreed to take part may have been those with fairly good relationships with their 16-year-olds. Thus, the results of the research may be biased due to the sample.

Institutionalized children don’t just suffer emotional privation but also poor physical care such as bad diet and also lack of stimulation.  As a result it is difficult to separate out the effects of privation and of physical care.

 

Further Information

A-level Psychology Attachment Revision Notes

Privation and Genie privation

RutterPrivation


References

Hodges, J. & Tizard, B. (1989) Social and family relationships of ex-institutional adolescents. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 30, 77-97.


How to cite this article:

McLeod, S. A. (2008). Hodges and Tizard. Retrieved from http://www.simplypsychology.org/hodges-tizard.html

https://www.simplypsychology.org/hodges-tizard.html

Post Written By Lizzie Christian. Copyrighted (c) 31.07.2017.

About rainbowwarriorlizzie

'I am a born again holy-spirit filled warrior saint of God' Christian Author / Poet and Spiritual Artist Human Rights & Political Activism Walking the Red Road AHO! For I am a Warrior of God I act in spite of Fear, in his Stealth, For I am a Warrior of God I am willing to do Whatever it takes, For I am a Warrior of God I do Everything at 100% in His Grace, For I am a Warrior of God I am Willing to do what's hard, in His Courage, For I am a Warrior of God I act in spite of my Moods in His Majesty, For I am a Warrior of God I am Bigger than Any Obstacle in His Might, For I am a Warrior of God I Succeed in spite of Anything, For I am a Warrior of God I will Never Give Up! For I am a Warrior of God Our father, Son Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit, In Jesus name AMEN I have been writing and submitting Poetry to Forward Press Publishing, Triumph House and Poetry Now, since 1998, with numerous works published in their themed Anthologies and represented the South Uk. Continuing with my Creative Writing and Poetry, have written and self~published my small books of Poetry. Currently writing a Book of Verse, Poems of Love, Mother Earth, Healing, Prayers, Heart and Spirit upon Life's Journey. Along side an exentsive portfoli of RAINBOW HEALING ART, working with Watercolour, Ink and Graphite. Colourwork shown in exhibition and take to local Craft fairs etc...Aho. I would like to thank you for reading my inspiring written 'works' that is a joy to write. Fore, you are my Inspiritation, you Enrich my life's journey. Sharing a little Peace, Harmony, Hope, faith in all we do as we walk along life's journey. May your Love Light shine, Heart and Spirit. Mitakuye Oyasin, All My Relations. My other name being 'Rainbow Earth Turtle' given by my Spirit Brother Robert 'Starfire Turtle' Bruce Carter (Choctaw/Cherokee/Irish) Sweet Mother, I feel your heartbeat dancing and prancing, love and life has sprung from you a bond so true, I honour you. Sweet Mother, I feel you under my feet, we walk upon your land with gentle kisses to your breeze your sweet caress, I honour thee. Fore, I stand tall, yet I am small a single thread, the web of life we weave, with love, respect I honor you.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s